Future Retirement Success
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Investing
  • Stocks
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Investing
  • Stocks

Future Retirement Success

Investing

There’s Nothing “Absurd” or “Dangerous” about Ending the US Department of Education

by July 22, 2024
July 22, 2024
There’s Nothing “Absurd” or “Dangerous” about Ending the US Department of Education

Neal McCluskey

If you ran a corporation, and a division you did not need suffered massive losses while proving either ineffective or downright incompetent at its job, you would seriously consider dissolving it, right? After all, not only is it not helping, it is an albatross around your neck.

That’s largely what the US Department of Education appears to be for American education. Yet if you propose eliminating it the first reaction from some people is shock and lament: “But it’s about education, so it must be good.” That seems to be the presumption of former Republican Maryland governor, and current Maryland Senate candidate, Larry Hogan, who in this weekend’s Washington Post dismissed the Project 2025 proposal to end the Department. He called it “absurd and dangerous.”

I cannot speak to Project 2025 as a whole because I have not read the vast majority of it. But I have read the section on the Department of Education, and far from being either “absurd” or “dangerous,” it is a thoughtful examination of not just the Department, but the whole federal role in education and how it can be reengineered. I, too, have written about removing the feds from education, including with Lindsey Burke, the author of the Project 2025 Department of Education chapter.

The Project 2025 chapter—which is really part of the most recent iteration of Heritage’s Mandate for Leadership—lays out K‑12 results on the National Assessment of Educational Progress and shows that mainly stagnation has accompanied major federal involvement, while it is hardly clear that what progress there has been was either sustainable or a result of Department of Education spending.

Much worse than K‑12 has been higher education, where the Department of Education has essentially run almost the entire student loan industry. In 2022, the GAO reported that twenty-five years’ worth of federal student loans would cost taxpayers nearly $200 billion due to forgiveness plans and other non-repayment. There is, though, difficulty in making estimates, in part because the Department has failed in its basic operations, including tracking borrower repayments, as documented in another 2022 GAO report. And while the Biden administration focused on unconstitutional mass student debt cancelation, the Department failed at another basic job: simplifying the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA).

The FAFSA is the gateway to student aid that is, unfortunately, baked into the price of college and, hence, necessary for many people to attend college. Of course, the necessity of aid is another major reason to end fed ed: it is a hugely negative, unintended consequence of federal “help” that is almost certainly a disease worse than the cure.

And do not think the feds have historically been essential for education. A major federal funding role only began in the mid-1960s; the Department has only existed since 1980. This is in large part because the Constitution gives the federal government no authority to govern education (alas, a point neglected in the Project 2025 chapter) and for most of our history few people would have imagined a major federal role.

Finally, just think of how fed ed works: The federal government takes money from taxpayers either today or in the future, hires thousands of people to tie rules and regulations to it— including some advancing highly controversial, values-laden policies—then returns what is left of the money with the rules and regs attached. That is hardly an efficient, or pluralism-respecting, way to deliver education.

In light of its unconstitutionality, failure, and cost, the stronger argument is not that eliminating the US Department of Education is “absurd and dangerous.” It is that keeping it is.

0
FacebookTwitterGoogle +Pinterest
previous post
How to Feel at Home: Tips to Blend in for New UK Residents 
next post
DP Trading Room: Behind the Scenes: CrowdStrike (CRWD)

You may also like

What’s Next for TikTok? A Brief Explanation

April 30, 2024

Universal Savings Accounts to Help Families Build Wealth

May 22, 2024

Study Finds GLP-1s Are Effectively Over-the-Counter Drugs in...

August 5, 2024

70% Say Founders Would Disagree with How We...

September 17, 2024

Breaking Down Taiwan’s Arms Backlog, Part 1: Overview...

November 6, 2023

Trump: “Kill FISA”

April 10, 2024

Employee Retention Credit Shows Folly of Tax Code...

October 12, 2023

The CFPB’s Digital Wallet Rule Proposal Reveals What’s...

November 22, 2023

Treasury Advisory Committee Calls for CBDCs to Replace...

November 4, 2024

To Reach Statehood, Puerto Rico Should Improve its...

January 2, 2024

What’s Next for TikTok? A Brief Explanation

April 30, 2024

Universal Savings Accounts to Help Families Build Wealth

May 22, 2024

Study Finds GLP-1s Are Effectively Over-the-Counter Drugs in...

August 5, 2024

70% Say Founders Would Disagree with How We...

September 17, 2024

Breaking Down Taiwan’s Arms Backlog, Part 1: Overview...

November 6, 2023

Trump: “Kill FISA”

April 10, 2024

Employee Retention Credit Shows Folly of Tax Code...

October 12, 2023

The CFPB’s Digital Wallet Rule Proposal Reveals What’s...

November 22, 2023

Treasury Advisory Committee Calls for CBDCs to Replace...

November 4, 2024

To Reach Statehood, Puerto Rico Should Improve its...

January 2, 2024

    Get free access to all of the retirement secrets and income strategies from our experts! or Join The Exclusive Subscription Today And Get the Premium Articles Acess for Free

    By opting in you agree to receive emails from us and our affiliates. Your information is secure and your privacy is protected.

    Recent Posts

    • Kash Patel torches ‘conspiracy theories’ about Bondi feud amid MAGA furor over Epstein files

      July 13, 2025
    • Trump defends embattled AG Pam Bondi, says ‘nobody cares about’ Jeffrey Epstein

      July 12, 2025
    • Bondi says all charges against doctor who allegedly destroyed COVID vaccines have been dropped

      July 12, 2025
    • Meet ‘China’s man in Lima’ who jetted over to US to collect trains donated by Biden admin

      July 12, 2025
    • Inside Dan Bongino’s tense meeting with White House officials over Jeffrey Epstein fallout

      July 12, 2025
    • Could Butler happen again? Former Secret Service agents weigh in on political violence in 2025

      July 12, 2025

    Categories

    • Business (8,456)
    • Investing (2,118)
    • Politics (16,018)
    • Stocks (3,205)
    • About us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions

    Disclaimer: futureretirementsuccess.com, its managers, its employees, and assigns (collectively “The Company”) do not make any guarantee or warranty about what is advertised above. Information provided by this website is for research purposes only and should not be considered as personalized financial advice. The Company is not affiliated with, nor does it receive compensation from, any specific security. The Company is not registered or licensed by any governing body in any jurisdiction to give investing advice or provide investment recommendation. Any investments recommended here should be taken into consideration only after consulting with your investment advisor and after reviewing the prospectus or financial statements of the company.

    Copyright © 2025 futureretirementsuccess.com | All Rights Reserved