Future Retirement Success
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Investing
  • Stocks
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Investing
  • Stocks

Future Retirement Success

Investing

Fourth Circuit: Tax Exempt Status Is Not Federal Financial Assistance

by May 17, 2024
May 17, 2024
Fourth Circuit: Tax Exempt Status Is Not Federal Financial Assistance

Walter Olson

In a pair of cases decided within weeks of each other in 2022, federal judges ruled that private schools’ tax‐​exempt status under section 501 (c) (3) of the tax code constituted “federal financial assistance” and thus subjected the schools to federal regulation under Title IX. For a while, it began to look as if the independence of schools that do not take federal money—among them Michigan’s Hillsdale College, as well as thousands of private and religious K‑12 institutions—was at risk. Now, in welcome news, a unanimous panel of the Fourth Circuit has reversed one of the rulings.

Donna Buettner‐​Hartsoe and her daughter sued the Baltimore Lutheran High School Association after the daughter was allegedly subjected to bullying and sexual harassment at Concordia Prep, a Lutheran high school in Towson. They sought to invoke the federal Title IX law on the grounds that the school was organized under the familiar tax exemption provisions of 501(c)(3) of the tax code, which apply to much of the nonprofit sector (including the Cato Institute).

Although considerable precedent suggested that tax exemption did not by itself constitute “federal financial assistance,” and the federal government itself had not sought to press such a claim, a Baltimore federal judge nonetheless agreed. Weeks later, a California federal judge adopted the same view in a case against a school called Valley Christian Academy. In that case, which is still pending, the judge also ruled that accepting money under the federal government’s Payroll Protection Program (PPP), which was intended to avert layoffs during the Covid pandemic, also separately constituted federal financial assistance for which it would have to submit to Title IX regulation.

Advocates were soon raising similar arguments elsewhere, including in a suit against Hillsdale College, the Michigan institution famous for spurning the federal dollar and the regulations that go with it. In December of last year, I spoke with Tunku Varadarajan for a piece he wrote on the Hillsdale College case for the Wall Street Journal. I said:

The proposition that nonprofit tax status should subject private institutions to the regulations applied to government grantees would be a radical departure from longstanding tax and legal principles and would put at risk the fundamental independence of America’s private charitable and educational sectors, to say nothing of its religious institutions.

Fortunately, back East, the Fourth Circuit panel was having none of it. In a ruling based on statutory interpretation, as opposed to the Constitution, the court marched through the text and its application over time, and distinguished cases in which federal financial assistance had been found in programs that granted students money to attend a school, thus assisting it indirectly. The court also distinguished the famous Bob Jones University case, in which a tax exemption was stripped for an institution for acting against settled public policy, as resting on an entirely different basis. (More here on why the logic of the Bob Jones case did not spread as far as some predicted.)

Let’s hope the Valley Christian Academy ruling from California is speedily reversed as well. America’s nonprofit sector should not be subjected to prolonged uncertainty about its legal status.

0
FacebookTwitterGoogle +Pinterest
previous post
Sen Durbin demands Justice Alito recuse from Trump cases after flying upside-down US flag
next post
Top 5 Stocks in “Go” Trends | Fri May 17, 2024

You may also like

How Large Is the Federal Debt?

October 10, 2023

Does Congress Really Believe it Can Thwart the...

December 13, 2023

Shedding Light on the Incidence of Illegal Noncitizen...

May 23, 2024

There Is No Good Reason to Revoke Birthright...

January 23, 2025

The Right to Control Your Property Is Fundamental

April 11, 2025

US Funding of the United Nations

March 19, 2025

The Occupational Licensing Elves on the Shelf

December 13, 2024

Four Things the Senate Can Do to Improve...

May 22, 2025

Latest Attempt to Restore Financial Privacy: the Saving...

September 25, 2024

Time for a Fresh Approach to Childcare

November 15, 2024

How Large Is the Federal Debt?

October 10, 2023

Does Congress Really Believe it Can Thwart the...

December 13, 2023

Shedding Light on the Incidence of Illegal Noncitizen...

May 23, 2024

There Is No Good Reason to Revoke Birthright...

January 23, 2025

The Right to Control Your Property Is Fundamental

April 11, 2025

US Funding of the United Nations

March 19, 2025

The Occupational Licensing Elves on the Shelf

December 13, 2024

Four Things the Senate Can Do to Improve...

May 22, 2025

Latest Attempt to Restore Financial Privacy: the Saving...

September 25, 2024

Time for a Fresh Approach to Childcare

November 15, 2024

    Get free access to all of the retirement secrets and income strategies from our experts! or Join The Exclusive Subscription Today And Get the Premium Articles Acess for Free

    By opting in you agree to receive emails from us and our affiliates. Your information is secure and your privacy is protected.

    Recent Posts

    • Businesses face £60,000 fines per illegal worker as HMRC and UKVI escalate crackdown

      July 10, 2025
    • UK government scraps ‘zonal pricing’ for energy in favour of single national rate

      July 10, 2025
    • UK and France join forces on navigation tech to protect critical infrastructure from hostile threats

      July 10, 2025
    • England loses eight bank branches a week since 2016

      July 10, 2025
    • PPE Medpro delivers final blow in DHSC trial, calling case ‘buyer’s remorse’ and evidence ‘non-existent’

      July 10, 2025
    • Royal Mail to scrap Saturday second-class deliveries in major overhaul

      July 10, 2025

    Categories

    • Business (8,437)
    • Investing (2,112)
    • Politics (15,988)
    • Stocks (3,197)
    • About us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions

    Disclaimer: futureretirementsuccess.com, its managers, its employees, and assigns (collectively “The Company”) do not make any guarantee or warranty about what is advertised above. Information provided by this website is for research purposes only and should not be considered as personalized financial advice. The Company is not affiliated with, nor does it receive compensation from, any specific security. The Company is not registered or licensed by any governing body in any jurisdiction to give investing advice or provide investment recommendation. Any investments recommended here should be taken into consideration only after consulting with your investment advisor and after reviewing the prospectus or financial statements of the company.

    Copyright © 2025 futureretirementsuccess.com | All Rights Reserved